Lily - V.C.U. (We See You)

Year of Release: 2002
Label: Garden Of Delights
Catalog Number: CD 062
Format: CD
Total Time: 79:06:00

Lily is not a name you'd associate with a German, jazz-rock inflected band whose vocalist often sounds a great deal like Jethro Tull's Ian Anderson. Seeing it, you might think it were the German answer to the UK's Lulu (who most know from her "To Sir With Love" song). And in fact, as the liner notes state at the outset, Lily was not the name the band initially used but rather Monsun. Lily was thrust upon them by Bellaphon records, hoping by giving them a "glitter image [to?] increase their chances of success." This is why on the cover they are wearing make up and women's clothes. Were Lily a glitter band? No, far from.

Lily were Manfred Schlagmüller on drums and percussion, Wilfried Kirchmeier on bass and vocals, Hans-Werner Steinberg (tenor and soprano saxes), and both Manfred-Josef Schmid and Klaus Lehmann on guitars. Schlagmüller and Kirchmeier play synths on "Eyes Look From The Mount Of Flash," which puts snappy percussive effects early on and squelchy effects as the song ends. V.C.U. (We See You) was recorded and released in 1973 (Bacillus), recording taking place at Deiter Dirks' studio. The band were given only three days studio time, only two of which were able to be used for recording. Vocals were left for the last day, and were, according to the liner notes, "recorded very quickly." This hurriedness shows in the unpolished nature of the pieces. Individual performances are good, but on some tracks the band seem out of sync. The one element that worked the least for me were the vocals of Wilfried Kirchmeier, at least at the outset, as they improve as the album moves along. In fact, the more he sounds like Anderson, the better they are. But given the time constraints, there was no time really to redo anything. If you can set that aside and listen to the band's playing, you'll find they were really quite good, especially drummer Schlagm¨ller (who is showcased on the best track on the album, the bonus track "The Wanderer." If you love and admire drumming, this is the track to skip to first - in fact, given the bass solo from Kirchmeier and the remaining performances on this instrumental track? you'll also want to skip to here first).

Oddly, the best tracks on this album overall are the bonus tracks, which were presumably recorded at the same time as the initial tracks - nothing is mentioned in the liner notes (strange coming from the usually very thorough Garden Of Delights). These might have seemed too "commercial" in comparison to the other material ("The Wanderer" aside), but stylistically, they seem to fit right in, though to my ears they seem a little more polished. They are mostly instrumental tracks, though they aren't solely instrumental. The bonus tracks include the mostly musing blues-jazz piece "Chemical New York," the highlight being the tenor sax playing of Steinberg. "Adlerbar" has an almost "Whole Lotta Love"/"Cross-Eyed Mary" rhythm to it owing to the fat, throbbing basslines of Kirchmeier and the roughened, ballsy guitar, all with Steinberg blowing tenor sax all over it (sometimes in a harmonica-like fashion) - cool stuff actually. "Catch Me" is a more upbeat, groovy piece with more sax and guitar up front. Kirchmeier sounds a bit like Jim Morrison on this piece.

In broad strokes, their sound is reminiscent of other jazz-rock-psychedelic bands of the period, certainly evident during the middle section of "Which Is This," which, if it were strictly instrumental, would be excellent - from the guitar solo to the saxes to the drumming. While Lily don't sound like any one band in particular, there were parts that reminded me of early Jethro Tull, as mentioned -- parts of "Which Is This," and "I'm Lying On My Belly (including 'Tango Atonale')" and "Chemical New York" (one of the bonus tracks) all of which suggest Anderson's gravelly vocal delivery on "Aqualung" ? somewhat. Comparatively, "I'm Lying?" is more simply arranged piece, where the band seem to be playing more in sync with each other, putting the guitar in the lead -- that is until a solo section, with soprano sax tootling over chiming electric guitars. Other parts that made me think of The Doors, Led Zeppelin, and Santana ... but it might be truer to say these bands were all influenced by a single source, which was the American blues. "Doctor Martin" is notable for its treatment of Kirchmeier's vocals where echoes ripple out and some good instrumental work that immediate follows.

At least on "Eyes Look?," it's Schmid soloing in your right ear, as his tone is said to be rougher than the clearing tone of Lehmann, who will be in your left ear. It is on the track that I first really hear Kirchmeier on bass, who, as I said, really gets to solo on "The Wanderer."

Lily were a band who given a little more time in the studio, might have produced a real gem of an album ? well a glittering gem of an album, rather than a gem in the rough, making them a glitter band of an entirely different sort. As it is, internal problems eventually lead the band's dissolution. Schmid was booted out of the band in December 1973, though it had been he that had "[produced] enormous amounts of musical ideas and strange lyrics [that were then] sorted, corrected, smoothed out and chronologically arranged by Wilfried Krichmeier?" (later "?Steinberg would add his wind instruments [?] while [Schlagmüller] provided the drum part. They would spend endless nights working on the tracks, rearranging them, until finally that very special Monsun sound emerged." - this is the genesis of the tracks on this album). After Schmid left, the band had lost their "musical originality." Other than writing songs "with mad German lyrics mirroring his mental problems" (Schmid had trashed the rehearsal room after having been booted from the band) and died under "mysterious circumstances" in the mid-90s, being "found dead in Frankfurt's inner-city wood." The band continued without Schmid, replacing him with guitarist Björn Scherer-Mohr, who leaves in August 1974. Schlagmüller leaves in early 1975, replaced by "Rüdigger "Rüpf" Pfau. By April 1976, the band have added humour to their music to the point where "their music becomes more and more jokey, approaching comedy?" and it is after their show at the Old Bailey in Bayreuth that month that the band dissolves.

In Those Times (9:08) / Which Is This (4:24) / Pinky Pigs (6:38) / Doctor Martin (4:36) / I'm Lying On My Belly (Including 'Tango Atonale') (5:57) / Eyes Look From The Mount Of Flash (9:43) / Bonus Tracks: Chemical New York (8:15) / Adlerbar (5:46) / Catch Me (8:12) / The Wanderer (16:27)

Wilfried Kirchmeier - bass, vocals; percussion (3, 6)
Manfred Schlagm?ller (drums, percussion; synths (6)
Hans-Werner Steinberg - tenor and soprano saxes
Manfred-Josef Schmid - guitar
Klaus Lehmann -guitars

Additional musicians:

Dieter Dierks -mellotron
Armin Bannach - gong

V.C.U. (We See You) (1973/2002)

Genre: Rock

Origin DE

Added: June 23rd 2003
Reviewer: Stephanie Sollow
Artist website:
Hits: 781
Language: english


[ Back to Reviews Index | Post Comment ]